Showing posts with label survey. Show all posts
Showing posts with label survey. Show all posts

Friday, October 21, 2011

AMERICAN YOUTH LOSING INTEREST IN HISTORY, CIVICS AND PATRIOTISM.
America Was Great Because We Were Good. Why Is American Greatness Now Fading?
“Failing Liberty 101”
By Walter E. Williams, professor of economics at George Mason University July 13, 2011

A recent Superman comic book has the hero saying, "I am renouncing my U.S. citizenship" because "truth, justice, and the American way -- it's not enough anymore." Though not addressing Superman's statement, Stanford University professor and Hoover Institution senior fellow William Damon explains how such a vision could emerge today but not yesteryear. The explanation is found in his article "American Amnesia," in Defining Ideas (7/1/2011), based upon his most recent book, "Failing Liberty 101: How We Are Leaving Young Americans Unprepared for Citizenship in a Free Society."

The National Assessment of Educational Progress reports that only 1 in 4 high-school seniors scored at least "proficient" in knowledge of U.S. citizenship. Civics and history were American students' worst subjects. Professor Damon said that for the past 10 years, his Stanford University research team has interviewed broad cross sections of American youths about U.S. citizenship. Here are some typical responses: "We just had (American citizenship) the other day in history. I forget what it was." Another said, "Being American is not really special. ... I don't find being an American citizen very important." Another said, "I don't want to belong to any country. It just feels like you are obligated to this country. I don't like the whole thing of citizen. ... It's like, citizen, no citizen; it doesn't make sense to me. It's, like, to be a good citizen -- I don't know, I don't want to be a citizen. ... It's stupid to me."

A law professor, whom Damon leaves unnamed, shares this vision in a recent book: "Longstanding notions of democratic citizenship are becoming obsolete. ... American identity is unsustainable in the face of globalization." Instead of commitment to a nation-state, "loyalties ... are moving to transnational communities defined by many different ways: by race, ethnicity, gender, religion, age, and sexual orientation." This law professor's vision is shared by many educators who look to "global citizenship" as the proper aim of civics instruction, de-emphasizing attachment to any particular country, such as the United States, pointing out that our primary obligation should be to the universal ideals of human rights and justice. To be patriotic to one's own country is seen as suspect because it may turn into a militant chauvinism or a dangerous "my country, right or wrong" vision.

The ignorance about our country is staggering. According to one survey, only 28 percent of students could identify the Constitution as the supreme law of the land. Only 26 percent of students knew that the first 10 amendments to the Constitution are called the Bill of Rights. Fewer than one-quarter of students knew that George Washington was the first president of the United States. . . .

Discouraging young Americans from identifying with their country and celebrating our traditional American quest for liberty and equal rights removes the most powerful motivation to learn civics and U.S. history. After all, Damon asks, "why would a student exert any effort to master the rules of a system that the student has no respect for and no interest in being part of? To acquire civic knowledge as well as civic virtue, students need to care about their country."
[Dr. Williams then editorialized as to the current state of American politics which was heavily partisan. These comments are not reprinted here.]



Walter E. Williams is a professor of economics at George Mason University.
From:
http://townhall.com/columnists/walterewilliams/2011/07/13/failing_liberty_101

Monday, November 20, 2006

FASSS STUDENT 'Celebrate Freedom Week'

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY - November 2006

In September 2006, the Florida Association of Social Studies Supervisors piloted a student poll to obtain information about students' knowledge and attitudes toward civic and historical understanding within the state of Florida. Despite intense lobbying for almost 30 years to be added to statewide assessment programs, Florida citizens still have no idea how well school districts are fulfilling their civic mission. The results of the draft survey of high school students included responses from 749 high school students. Teachers were to explain to students the need to be honest in light of the total darkness in which the state operates regarding civic knowledge among our youth. Some attitudinal questions were deliberately included because it was thought this might be revealing as opposed to the typical headline getting "Kids Can Identify the Long Dead 3 Stooges Better than Our 3 Branches of Government" material that other national surveys have resorted to. For this reason and to help eliminate 'guessing', the survey also included "I Don't Know" as an option for many of the questions. Moreover, in order to gauge the extent to which students might have been making light of the survey, two open-ended questions were utilized to which students could respond with any comment. These techniques helped to ensure that almost all students took the poll seriously.

The demographics of the Sample are not too far out of line with Florida's demographics at the high school level. Several indicators among the data give the impression that these were above average students. A summary of the results revealed that

• Whereas approximately 45% of the high school respondents said they themselves were knowledgeable and interested in history and politics only about 12% felt their peers were. (This may lead us to assume mostly academically rigorous or 'Honors' classes took the survey.)
• Less than half the students knew Condoleeza Rice was Secretary of State, despite her almost daily being in the news last fall before the national election.
• Only 16% of the students knew the U.S. House has 435 members.
• Only one-fifth knew the term of office for U.S. Senators.
• Only one-fourth could identify 'Roe vs Wade'.
• Less than one-fourth could identify the purpose of the Electoral College.
• Only about one in ten could identify the source of the phrase, "Government of the People, by the People, for the People".
• Almost one half thought Lincoln is best remembered for "promising as a Presidential Candidate to eliminate slavery." ( Less than 14% selected that he had "preserved the union" - the only true statement among those given.)
• Only about one-fourth knew FDR was President during WWII - about the same who thought T.R. was the correct response.
• Almost four fifths thought the philosophy "from each according to his ability, to each according to his need" came from a sacred American document such as the Bill of Rights, the Mayflower Compact or the Declaration of Independence.
• Less than one-fourth could correctly identify the Emancipation Proclamation.
• Only one-fourth knew the correct quarter-century when the Civil War took place.
• Only 17 of 747 (2%) students could name BOTH of Florida's two U.S. Senators. (This was only days before Senator Bill Nelson stood for reelection.)
• Only 9 of 749 (1%) students could name, in any way, two U.S. Supreme Court Justices.

FASSS urges accountability for the civic mission of Florida's Public Schools!

(For more information contact Jack Bovee at boveeja@collier.k12.fl.us )

Wednesday, May 3, 2006

FCSS Members Support Testing!

FCSS members at the 2001 State Conference in Tampa were asked whether they supported testing in our area. Overwhelmingly the survey results showed that they did. A copy of the survey, conducted by the FCSS Legislative Committee is shown below.

Wednesday, January 11, 2006

POLL SHOWS NEED FOR MORE CIVIC EDUCATION FOR FLORIDA ADULTS


FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE January 11, 2006
CONTACT: Francine Andia Walker,
The Florida Barwww.FloridaBar.org
TELEPHONE: 850/561-5666

Ninety percent or more of Florida adult residents say the constitutional concepts of separation of powers and checks and balances are important principles in the federal government, according to a new poll conducted by Harris Interactive® for The Florida Bar.

But when asked “What are the three branches of government?” only 59 percent of the Florida adults surveyed chose the correct answer: legislative, executive and judicial. The second most frequent answer was “local, state and federal” (18 percent), followed by “Republican, Democrat and Independent” (16 percent). Questions about the meaning of the terms “separation of powers” and “checks and balances” also yielded low percentages of correct answers (46 percent and 61 percent respectively).

The results of the Florida poll (see poll questions) are similar to those of a national poll that asked the same questions done by the American Bar Association in July 2005. The national poll report is available at www.abaconstitution.org.

“After seeing the national results, The Florida Bar became very concerned about our own citizens’ knowledge of these vital principles of democracy, Alan B. Bookman, President of The Florida Bar, said. “We discovered that Floridians score an A on recognizing the importance of the constitutional concepts, but get an F on defining separation of powers and checks and balances, and a D on identifying the three government branches.”

The American Bar Association came to the same conclusion after conducting its poll -- that the majority of Americans could use a civics refresher course.

With this report card in hand, The Florida Bar is setting out to advocate for more public awareness and education on civics. For example, the organization will use its statewide Speakers Bureau and its Citizens Forum, a non-lawyer advisory group, to go out to civic and community groups with presentations on civics. Throughout the state, local bar associations will support many community-based educational activities, particularly during national Law Week in May which is themed “Liberty Under Law: Separate Branches, Balanced Powers.” In addition, the Bar is asking the media to become involved in civic education, especially in coverage leading up to the 2006 elections.

At the same time, The Florida Bar is targeting a revitalization of civic education for the state's youth.

“As we questioned the civic knowledge of adults, we also looked at the state of civic education in Florida. Although civic education has historically been a primary mission of American public education, it appears that this commitment is fading,” Bookman said.

According to the Florida Law Related Education Association, less than 10 percent of Florida’s 67 counties require the teaching of civics in middle school. High school students are required only to take a one semester government course, usually in the senior year, but law-related education experts say that requirement is too little, too late.Bookman said that the Bar is concerned about giving young people the knowledge they need to value and participate in democracy. “We’d like to see 100 percent of Florida middle schools providing a mandatory yearlong course in applied civics,” Bookman said.

“As we speak to adults and the media about civics and civic education, we are asking that they assess their own school districts’ civics offerings and talk to local superintendents and school boards about providing required yearlong civics courses,” he added.

The Florida Law Related Education Association created the Florida Civic Alliance to promote civic education in Florida’s K-12 public school system through a broad-based plan addressing curriculum reform, state and local policy, public awareness and coalition building. A complete middle school course has been developed for local districts, based on Miami-Dade’s required civics course, and Palm Beach County adopted and implemented that curriculum in the 2005-6 school year according to the law related education association.

The bottom line for The Florida Bar is that if citizens don’t understand what makes democracy work, they are just as likely not to understand the essential components of an independent judiciary – that the judiciary be fair and impartial.

“America’s enduring strength flows from our Constitution and its mandate that there be three separate but equal branches of government. We must educate the public and remind them that without a strong and vibrant rule of law, our democracy will simply cease to exist,” Bookman said.

Harris Interactive® conducted a telephone survey on behalf of The Florida Bar between December 27 and 29, 2005, among 400 adults from Florida aged 18 and over. Figures for age, sex, race, education, number of adults and number of voice/telephone lines in the household were weighted where necessary to align them with their actual proportions in the population. In theory, with a probability sample of this size, one could say with 95 percent certainty that the results have a sampling error of plus or minus five percentage points of what they would be if the entire Florida adult population had been polled with complete accuracy.

The Florida Bar is the statewide professional and regulatory organization for all lawyers licensed to practice in Florida.About Harris Interactive®Harris Interactive Inc.

(www.harrisinteractive.com), based in Rochester, New York, is the 13th largest and the fastest-growing market research firm in the world, most widely known for The Harris Poll® and for its pioneering leadership in the online market research industry. Long recognized by its clients for delivering insights that enable confident business decisions, the Company blends the science of innovative research with the art of strategic consulting to deliver knowledge that leads to measurable and enduring value.Harris Interactive serves clients worldwide through its United States, Europe (www.harrisinteractive.com/europe) and Asia offices, its wholly-owned subsidiary Novatris in Paris, France (www.novatris.com), and through an independent global network of affiliate market research companies.
x
EDITORS: Please note The Florida Bar is not an association and "Association" is not part of our name. Proper reference is "The Florida Bar." Local bar organizations are properly termed "associations."

[Updated: 02-02-2006 ]

Wednesday, March 3, 2004

Status on the State of Civic Education in Florida

Classroom Teacher Survey - 2004

Our organizations are interested in hearing from classroom teachers regarding the status of Civic Education in Florida. Please take a moment, complete the survey below, and return it to the person at the end of the survey. Thank you. (Textboxes are provided in the appropriate blanks. Simply ‘left click’ on the blank, make the text box appear and then type directly in the box to make an electronic version of your response.)

1. Your name (optional) ____________________________

2. Grade / Subject you teach _________________________

3. District ______________________________________

4. Number of years you have been teaching social studies. _____
(Over 5 years preferred.)

For the following statements, circle the word or number you MOST AGREE WITH.


5. In the last five years, I have seen the daily minutes or time devoted to Social Studies instruction to
a. be greatly increased.
b. be slightly increased.
c. remain the same
d. to be slightly decreased.
e. to be greatly decreased.
____
6. My current social studies textbooks are
a. less than six years old.
b. more than six, but less than 8 years old.
c. more than 8, but less than 10 years old.
d. more than 10 years old.
____
7. Which statement below is most accurate with regard to the status of current wall maps in your classroom? Check ALL that apply.
a. the current maps in my classroom are the original ones that were furnished when the school was built. The number of years old your school is ____.
b. I have a world maps less than 10 years old. (Eritrea is shown as part of former Ethiopia & Russia is shown with the Independent Commonwealth States of the former U.S.S.R.)
c. I have a world map that is from BEFORE 1992. (Yugoslavia is shown or U.S.S.R.)
d. I have a world map from BEFORE 1990 (East and West Germany are shown).
e. I do NOT have a world map in my classroom.____

8. In my estimation, students are coming to my classroom in recent years with
a. the SAME basic civic knowledge as they have had in the past.
b. SLIGHTLY MORE civic understanding than they have had in the past.
c. a GREAT DEAL MORE civic understanding than they have had in the past.
d. SLIGHTLY LESS civic understanding than they have had in the past.
c. a GREAT DEAL LESS civic understanding than they have had in the past.
____
9. In my estimation, students are coming to my classroom in recent years with
a. the SAME basic knowledge of history as they have had in the past.
b. SLIGHTLY MORE historical understanding than they have had in the past.
c. a GREAT DEAL MORE historical understanding than they have had in the past.
d. SLIGHTLY LESS historical understanding than they have had in the past.
c. a GREAT DEAL LESS historical understanding than they have had in the past.
____
10. In my estimation, students are coming to my classroom in recent years with
a. the SAME basic knowledge of geography as they have had in the past.
b. SLIGHTLY MORE geographical understanding than they have had in the past.
c. a GREAT DEAL MORE geographical understanding than they have had in the past.
d. SLIGHTLY LESS geographical understanding than they have had in the past.
c. a GREAT DEAL LESS geographical understanding than they have had in the past.
____
11. In my estimation, students are coming to my classroom in recent years with
a. the SAME basic knowledge of economics as they have had in the past.
b. SLIGHTLY MORE economic understanding than they have had in the past.
c. a GREAT DEAL MORE economic understanding than they have had in the past.
d. SLIGHTLY LESS economic understanding than they have had in the past.
c. a GREAT DEAL LESS economic understanding than they have had in the past.

12. Have you heard of or do you personally know of another teacher who has been asked to lessen the emphasis on social studies instruction in the last few years?
___ yes __ no

13. What is the current amount of TIME (minutes or hours per week, days per term or semester) that is devoted to social studies instruction at your school? If there has been a reduction from an earlier time, please state the percent of time for which this instruction has been reduced.

14. Have historical field trips to museums or other programs been affected in recent years?
___ yes __ no In needed, explain:

Please feel free to attach any additional anecdotal information regarding the status of student understanding of social studies content when they come to your school or classroom.